Innovation in business model as a response to the sharing economy

  1. Daniel Espinosa Sáez 1
  2. Elena Delgado-Ballester 1
  3. José Luis Munuera-Alemán 1
  1. 1 Universidad de Murcia
    info

    Universidad de Murcia

    Murcia, España

    ROR https://ror.org/03p3aeb86

Revista:
European journal of management and business economics

ISSN: 2444-8494,  2444-8451

Año de publicación: 2023

Volumen: 32

Número: 5

Páginas: 602-619

Tipo: Artículo

DOI: 10.1108/EJMBE-06-2022-0187 DIALNET GOOGLE SCHOLAR lock_openAcceso abierto editor

Otras publicaciones en: European journal of management and business economics

Resumen

Purpose The sharing economy (SE) is significantly affecting traditional companies, which have felt a need to adapt their business model. The aim of this study is to identify the different types of adaptation developed by companies within a SE context, and to examine how they relate to their characteristics. Design/methodology/approach A content analysis involving 149 real-world adaptation cases was carried out, after which a Kruskal–Wallis test and a multiple correspondence analysis were used to explore the relationships between the types of adaptation identified, the business characteristics and the strategic decisions taken for these adaptations. Findings Through the analyses proposed in the study, the main conclusions suggest that the way companies adapt to SE is related to business characteristics and the strategic decisions taken for these actions, demonstrating throughout the article what types of adaptations are made depending on variables such as sector of activity or business orientation. Originality/value This study is the first to examine the variables affecting the decisions among traditional companies in response to the SE. In addition, this work explores the SE from the business point of view, shedding light on the participation in SE by traditional companies.

Referencias bibliográficas

  • Adner,R. (2006), “Matchyour innovationstrategytoyour innovationecosystem”,HarvardBusiness Review,Vol. 84No. 4,p. 98.
  • Agarwal,N.andSteinmetz,R. (2019),“Sharingeconomy:asystematicliteraturereview”,International Journal of InnovationandTechnologyManagement,Vol. 16No. 06, 1930002.
  • Arimond, G. andElfessi,A. (2016), “Aclusteringmethod for categorical data in tourismmarket segmentationresearch”, Journal ofTravelResearch,Vol. 39No. 4,pp.391-397.
  • Battisti, S. andBrem,A. (2021), “Digital entrepreneurs intechnology-basedspinoffs: ananalysisof hybridvaluecreationinretailpublic–privatepartnershipstotackleshowrooming”, Journalof BusinessandIndustrialMarketing,Vol. 36No. 10,pp.1780-1792.
  • Belezas,F.andDaniel,A.D. (2022),“Innovationinthesharingeconomy:asystematicliteraturereview andresearchframework”,Technovation,Vol. 122, 102509.
  • Belk,R. (2014),“Youarewhatyoucanaccess:sharingandcollaborativeconsumptiononline”,Journal ofBusinessResearch,Vol.67No.8,pp. 1595-1600.
  • Bocken,N.M.P.,Short,S.W.,Rana,P.andEvans,S. (2014),“Aliteratureandpracticereviewtodevelop sustainablebusinessmodelarchetypes”, Journal ofCleanerProduction,Vol. 65,pp. 42-56.
  • Cantu,C.L.,Schepis,D.,Minunno,R. andMorrison,G. (2021), “Theroleof relationalgovernance in innovationplatformgrowth: the context of living labs”, Journal ofBusiness and Industrial Marketing,Vol. 36No. 13,pp.236-249.
  • Carlborg, P.J., Hasche, N. andKask, J. (2021), “Overcoming the businessmodel transformation dilemma: exploringmarketshapingandstabilizingstrategies inincumbent firms”, Journal of BusinessandIndustrialMarketing,Vol. 36No. 13,pp.66-77.
  • Chang, H.H. and Sokol, D.D. (2022), “How incumbents respond to competition from innovative disruptors in the sharingeconomy—the impact ofAirbnbonhotel performance”, Strategic Management Journal,Vol. 43No. 3,pp.425-446.
  • Chang,H.C.,Wang,C.Y.andHawamdeh,S. (2019),“Emergingtrendsindataanalyticsandknowledge management jobmarket: extendingKSAframework”, Journal ofKnowledgeManagement, Vol.23No.4,pp. 664-686.
  • Chen,Y. andWang,L. (2019), “Commentary:marketingandthesharingeconomy: digital economy andemergingmarketchallenges”, JournalofMarketing,Vol. 83No.5,pp. 28-31.
  • Chien, F.S. (2022), “Themediating role of energy efficiencyon the relationshipbetweensharing economybenefitsandsustainabledevelopmentgoals (CaseofChina)”, Journal of Innovation andKnowledge,Vol. 7No.4,100270.
  • Child, J.,Faulkner,D.andPitkethly,R. (2001),TheManagementofInternationalAcquisitions,Oxford UniversityPress,NewYork.
  • Ciulli,F.andKolk,A. (2019), “Incumbentsandbusinessmodel innovationforthesharingeconomy: implicationsforsustainability”, Journal ofCleanerProduction,Vol. 214,pp. 995-1010.
  • Coombes, P. (2022), “Areviewof businessmodel research: what next for industrial marketing scholarship?”, Journal ofBusinessandIndustrialMarketing,Vol. 38No.3,pp. 520-532.
  • Das,S.,Avelar,R.,Dixon,K.andSun,X. (2018),“Investigationonthewrongwaydrivingcrashpatterns usingmultiplecorrespondenceanalysis”,AccidentAnalysisandPrevention,Vol.111,pp.43-55.
  • Eckhardt, G.M., Houston, M.B., Jiang, B., Lamberton, C., Rindfleisch, A. andZervas, G. (2019), “Marketinginthesharingeconomy”, Journal ofMarketing,Vol. 83No. 5,pp. 5-27.
  • Edelman,B.,Luca,M.andSvirsky,D. (2017),“Racialdiscriminationinthesharingeconomy:evidence fromafieldexperiment”,AmericanEconomicJournal:AppliedEconomics,Vol.9No.2,pp.1-22.
  • EuropeanCommision(2018), “Theuseof thecollaborativeeconomy(issueoctober)”.
  • EuropeanCommision (2016), “Theuseof collaborativeplatforms”, FlashEurobarometer,Vol. 438, availableat:http://ec.europa.eu/commfrontoffice/publicopinion/index.cfm/ResultDoc/download/ DocumentKy/72885
  • Ferrell,O.C.,Ferrell,L. andHuggins,K. (2017), “Seismicshifts inthesharingeconomy: shakingup marketingchannelsandsupplychains”, Journal ofMarketingChannels,Vol. 24,pp.3-12.
  • Francis, J. andSmith,A. (1995), “Agencycostsandinnovationsomeempirical evidence”, Journal of AccountingandEconomics,Vol. 19Nos2-3,pp.383-409.
  • Garud,R.,Kumaraswamy,A.,Roberts,A.andXu,L. (2022), “Liminalmovementbydigitalplatformbased sharing economy ventures: the case of Uber Technologies”, StrategicManagement Journal,Vol. 43No. 3,pp.447-475.
  • Gerwe, O. and Silva, R. (2020), “Clarifying the sharing economy: conceptualization, typology, antecedents, andeffects”,AcademyofManagementPerspectives,Vol. 34No.1,pp. 65-96.
  • Govindan,K.,Shankar,K.andKannan,D. (2020),“Achievingsustainabledevelopmentgoalsthrough identifyingandanalyzingbarrierstoindustrialsharingeconomy:aframeworkdevelopment”, International Journal ofProductionEconomics,Vol. 227, 107575.
  • Hamari, J., Sj€ oklint,M. andUkkonen,A. (2016), “Thesharingeconomy:whypeopleparticipate in collaborativeconsumption”, JournaloftheAssociationforInformationScienceandTechnology, Vol.67No.9,pp. 2047-2059.
  • Hossain,M. (2020), “Sharingeconomy: acomprehensive literature review”, International Journal of HospitalityManagement,Vol. 87, 102470.
  • Hsu,C.C. (2023),“Theroleofthecorecompetenceandcoreresourcefeaturesofasharingeconomyon theachievementofSDGs2030”, Journal of InnovationandKnowledge,Vol. 8No.1,100283.
  • Jiang,B.,Tian,L.,Xu,Y.andZhang,F. (2016),“Toshareornottoshare:demandforecastsharingina distributionchannel”,MarketingScience,Vol. 35No. 5,pp. 800-809.
  • Jordäo,R.V.D., Souza,A.^ O.A. andAvelar,E.A. (2014), “Organizational cultureandpost-acquisition changesinmanagementcontrolsystems:ananalysisofasuccessfulBraziliancase”, Journalof BusinessResearch,Vol. 67No. 4,pp.542-549.
  • Joseph, D.,Windham-Bannister, S. andMangold,M. (2021), “What corporates cando tohelpan innovationecosystemthrive–andwhytheyshoulddoit”, JournalofCommercialBiotechnology, Vol.26No.1,pp. 3-12.
  • Kang, Y., Lee, S. and Chung, B.D. (2019), “Learning-based logistics planning and scheduling for crowdsourcedparceldelivery”,ComputersandIndustrialEngineering,Vol.132No.2019,pp.271-279.
  • Kanter,R.M. (1994), “Collaborativeadvantage”,HarvardBusinessReview,Vol. 72No. 4,pp.96-108.
  • Karim, S. andMitchell, W. (2004), “Innovating through acquisition and internal development: aquarter-centuryofboundaryevolutionatJohnson&Johnson”,LongRangePlanning,Vol.37 No.6,pp.525-547.
  • Keko,E.,Prevo,G.J.andStremersch,S. (2018),“Thewhat,whoandhowofinnovationgeneration”, in Golder,P.N.andMitra,D. (Eds),HandbookofResearchonNewProductDevelopment,Edward ElgarPublishing,pp.37-59.
  • Kim,K.,Baek,C.andLee, J.D. (2018),“Creativedestructionofthesharingeconomyinaction: thecase ofUber”,TransportationResearchPartA:PolicyandPractice,Vol. 110,pp.118-127.
  • Klotz, F. (2018), “Manufacturers canalsowin in the sharingeconomy”,MITSloanManagement Review,Vol. 49No. 2,pp.1-5
  • Konietzko, J., Bocken,N. andHultink, E.J. (2020), “Circular ecosysteminnovation: an initial set of principles”, Journal ofCleanerProduction,Vol.253, 119942.
  • Kumar,V.,Lahiri,A.andDogan,O.B. (2018),“Astrategicframeworkforaprofitablebusinessmodel inthesharingeconomy”, IndustrialMarketingManagement,Vol. 69,pp.147-160.
  • Lee, G.K. andLieberman,M.B. (2010), “Acquisitionvs internal development asmodes ofmarket entry”,StrategicManagement Journal,Vol. 31No.2,pp.140-158.
  • Li,Y., Bai,X. andXue,K. (2020), “Businessmodes in the sharingeconomy: howdoes theOEM cooperatewiththird-partysharingplatforms?”, International JournalofProductionEconomics, Vol.221, 117467.
  • Mai,E.S. andKetron, S. (2022), “Howretailerownershipofvscollaborationwithsharingeconomy appsaffectsanticipatedservicequalityandvalueco-creation”, Journal ofBusinessResearch, Vol.140,pp. 684-692.
  • Massi, M., Rod, M. andCorsaro, D. (2021), “Is co-created value the only legitimate value?An institutional-theoryperspectiveonbusinessinteractioninB2B-marketingsystems”, Journalof BusinessandIndustrialMarketing,Vol. 36No. 2,pp.337-354.
  • Matzler, K., Veider, V. andKathan,W. (2015), “Adapting to the sharing economy”,MITSloan ManagementReview,Vol. 56No.2,pp.71-77.
  • Melander,L.andArvidsson,A. (2021),“Introducingsharing-focusedbusinessmodelsintheB2Bcontext: comparing interaction and environmental sustainability for selling, renting and sharing on industrialmarkets”, JournalofBusinessandIndustrialMarketing,Vol.36No.10,pp.1864-1875.
  • Moreau,C.P.,Franke,N.andvonHippel,E. (2018), “Theparadigmshift fromproducertoconsumer innovation: implicationsforconsumerresearch”, inGolder,P.N.andMitra,D. (Eds),Handbook ofResearchonNewProductDevelopment,EdwardElgarPublishing,pp. 81-99.
  • Mouratidis,K.,Peters,S.andvanWee,B. (2021),“Transportationtechnologies,sharingeconomy,and teleactivities: implicationsforbuiltenvironmentandtravel”,TransportationResearchPartD: TransportandEnvironment,Vol. 92, 102716.
  • Parchomenko,A.,Nelen,D.,Gillabel, J.andRechberger,H. (2019), “Measuringthecirculareconomyamultiple correspondence analysisof 63metrics”, Journal ofCleanerProduction, Vol. 210, pp.200-216.
  • PwC(2015),“Thesharingeconomy-consumerintelligenceseries”,availableat:https://www.pwc.com/ us/en/industry/entertainment-media/publications/consumer-intelligence-series/assets/pwc-cissharing-economy.pdf
  • PwC(2018), “Shareeconomy2017.Thenewbusinessmodel”, availableat: https://www.pwc.de/de/ digitale-transformation/share-economy-report-2017.pdf
  • Richard,B.andCleveland,S. (2016),“Thefutureofhotelchains:brandedmarketplacesdrivenbythe sharingeconomy”, Journal ofVacationMarketing,Vol. 22No. 3,pp.239-248.
  • Rita,P.,Ramos,R.F.,Moro,S.,Mealha,M. andRadu,L. (2021), “Onlinedatingappsasamarketing channel:agenerationalapproach”,EuropeanJournalofManagementandBusinessEconomics, Vol.30No.1,pp. 1-17.
  • Rojanakit,P.,TorresdeOliveira,R. andDulleck,U. (2022), “Thesharingeconomy: acritical review andresearchagenda”, Journal ofBusinessResearch,Vol. 139,pp.1317-1334.
  • Sadiq,M.,Moslehpour,M.,Qiu,R.,Hieu,V.M.,Duong,K.D.andNgo,T.Q. (2023), “Sharingeconomy benefits and sustainable development goals: empirical evidence from the transportation industryofVietnam”, Journal of InnovationandKnowledge,Vol. 8No. 1,100290.
  • Sanasi, S.,Ghezzi,A.,Cavallo,A. andRangone,A. (2020), “Makingsenseof thesharingeconomy: abusinessmodel innovationperspective”, TechnologyAnalysis andStrategicManagement, Vol.32No.8,pp. 895-909.
  • Thomas, L.D. andRitala, P. (2022), “Ecosystemlegitimacy emergence: a collective actionview”, Journal ofManagement,Vol. 48No.3,pp. 515-541. EJMBE 32,5 618
  • Tuffery,S. (2011),DataMiningandStatisticsforDecisionMaking, JohnWiley&Sons,Chichester.
  • Urbinati,A., Chiaroni, D. andChiesa, V. (2017), “Towards anewtaxonomyof circular economy businessmodels”, Journal ofCleanerProduction,Vol. 168,pp.487-498.
  • Xie,X. andWang,H. (2020), “Howcanopeninnovationecosystemmodespushproduct innovation forward?AnfsQCAanalysis”, Journal ofBusinessResearch,Vol. 108,pp.29-41.
  • Zervas,G., Proserpio,D. andByers, J.W. (2017), “The riseof thesharingeconomy: estimatingthe impact of Airbnb on the hotel industry”, Journal ofMarketingResearch, Vol. 54No. 5, pp.687-705.
  • Zhang, J., Yu, B. andLu, C. (2021), “Exploring the effects of innovation ecosystemmodels on innovativeperformancesofstart-ups: thecontingentroleofopeninnovation”,Entrepreneurship ResearchJournal,20200529.
Fuente de los datos: Dialnet